Opinion in the different parts of Kurdistan over the autonomous cantons of Syrian Kurdistan (Rojava) has been for the most part divided. But in the midst of it all one thing is clear: Strong central rule in Syria, exercised first by Hafez Assad and now by his son Bashar, has come to an end. This prepares the ground for a small state or federal region in Rojava. This means the cantons will last even if in a different form.
I have written on the situation in Rojava a number of times in the past and my opinion has always attracted both criticism and support. Now, I say that the autonomous cantons will survive and that they may also gain some sort of international recognition. But at the same time, I believe that one-party rule and restricting the activities of other groups would be detrimental to democracy and isolates the region – both to the outside world and from within.
Meanwhile, it should be noted that, with their attitude, the Kurdish parties of Rojava who are standing against the Democratic Union Party (PYD) will lose even their own supporters to the latter. A party means political stance. In time of revolution and change a party should take a stance and show it with deeds. Not like these parties which have limited themselves to mere statements.
A people who are under attack from radical groups and live in a vacuum have no use for statements and press releases. They need their party to be at least by their side, if not in front.
Two ideas and methods have visible influence on the ground in Rojava: That of Barzani, head of the Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) and those of Abdullah Ocalan, head of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), though the latter is played out through the PYD and the Al-Party.
However, Al-Party did not live up to the moment and did not act in a way that would satisfy the followers of Barzani’s path. Most Al-Party leaders ended up outside Rojava and gave in to PYD’s refusal to form a joint defense force. In short, they turned into an opposition group.
Al-Parti should have created its own area of influence and administration or it should have pushed for joint work. But the situation has now come to a point that they have much more work to do. Staying still and only reacting to PYD’s move will mean a deliberate death of these other groups.
Attending international opposition conferences without concrete plans on the ground in Rojava will do them no good.
A lesson can be found in the Iraqi opposition conference prior to the 2003 Iraq war, which was held in London and Erbil. Back then Ahmad Chalabi, the head of the Iraqi National Congress (INC) had full American support. He seemed to be the man who would lead Iraq. But after the war his party won only one seat in parliament and Chalabi himself ended up an ineffectual politician.
A one-party rule can change the direction of people in the time of war and abnormal circumstances. There may not be economic progress or pluralism, but nonetheless the single party is the one running the stage. It would spawn its ideas in all fields of life and society. At this stage the PYD has, in the absence of other groups, won itself a place in Kurdish history.
But there is still a chance to make the cantons belong to all. Through reconciliation and preparing the ground for elections in which all parties can participate. This can be done by the involvement of all groups. Through establishing joint security and defense forces. These steps will be in the best interest of the Kurdish people and the Kurdish National Council (KNC). It will also greatly benefit the PYD in the international arena.



