Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Kurdistan

Analysis: Sunni Insurgents and Kurds Untangling Iraq's “Artificial” Borders

By 31/7/2014
A Kurdish Peshmerga planting the flag of Kurdistan in Kirkuk, June 2014. Photo: Rudaw
A Kurdish Peshmerga planting the flag of Kurdistan in Kirkuk, June 2014. Photo: Rudaw

MONTREAL, Canada — The recent seizures of swaths of land by the Kurds and Sunni insurgents in Iraq has called into question borders that were drawn nearly a century ago. Since the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) launched its assault on the Iraqi city of Mosul in early June, Iraq has effectively been partitioned.

Jihadist-led Sunni rebels proclaimed a “caliphate” stretching from Aleppo in Syria to Diyala, northeast of Baghdad, while Kurdistan Region President Massoud Barzani signaled the Kurds would take steps towards independence including new territories Kurdish fighters seized in the north. Iraq’s Shia prime minister, Nouri al-Maliki, has been left in control of Baghdad and of the south.

Iraq was carved out under the secret 1916 Sykes-Picot agreement, through which the British and French partitioned their respective spheres of influence after World War I.

“New state borders were drawn in European capitals without giving any regard to the historical and local conditions. Lines were drawn in the sand, in the mountains and in the towns and villages of the MENA (Middle East and North Africa.) Within a short period of time, people became members of new political entities,” Khaled Salih, vice chancellor of the University of Kurdistan in Erbil, told Rudaw in an email interview.

“Most of these artificially created borders divided and combined different ethnicities and sectarian groups which today have created enormous problems in Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon,” agreed Michael M. Gunter, Professor at Tennessee Technological University and an expert on Kurdish affairs.

“It is not so much up to us to re-consider how these borders were originally drawn, as much as it is up to us to accommodate ourselves to the changes that are now occurring particularly in Syria and Iraq involving the Kurds and the lines of separation between the Sunni and Shiite,” Gunter maintained.

The secret accord initially aimed to secure French and British trade and oil interests along with creating artificial nation-states, which proved problematic early on.

“No place in the Middle East is truly homogeneous and one of the big challenge of creating national boundaries is that those minorities need to be integrated or they suffer repression,” Howard Eissenstat, history professor at the University of St-Lawrence in New York and an expert in the late Ottoman Empire, told Rudaw in a phone interview.

The recent territorial claims by Sunni insurgents and the open Kurdish pursuit of independence are perhaps the biggest threat Iraq’s unity — and the Sykes-Picot agreement — since the nation was conceived.

“With the collapse of the political orders in many states — particularly in Syria, Iraq and Libya — the notion of the nation-state has come tremendous pressure. It is now very likely that these states can be altered by internal forces from within these countries and by trans-border cooperation between armed groups,” Salih said.

Baghdad is now caught between the Kurds and ISIS, which have no interest in Iraq’s unity. Barzani, the president of the autonomous Kurdish region, is moving forward with the plan for statehood as Baghdad fails to shift its policy toward Erbil or deliver the Kurdistan Region’s budget, which Baghdad cut in January over oil disputes.

“Until recently, an independent state of Kurdistan was considered beyond the pale because it seemed to threaten the territorial integrity of the existing states. However, in recent years, the region has had plenty of time to adjust to the idea of Kurdish empowerment and with the seemingly collapse of Iraq and Syria as we knew them, at least independence for the KRG,” Gunter told Rudaw.

Last week the Kurdistan Region’s Parliament passed a law to create an electoral commission independent of Baghdad, paving the way for a referendum on Kurdish independence.

Yet unless it becomes more moderate, the extremist ISIS militia “in theory threatens all the existing states in the Middle East, possibly the KRG and Israel even more than the Arab states, because the KRG and Israel are not Arab,” Gunter said.

“Although changes in the existing borders in favor of the KRG and Sunnis in Iraq and Syria now seem inevitable, too many changes too quickly would probably lead to instability,” Gunter warned.

 

 

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Arin Meberg | 31/7/2014
Enough this stupidity of playing with Kurdish nation. Why we elect a president to F.. Shia Iraq? Why our tribe leaders are wasting time? Please press on your rich leaders Barzani and Talabani to declare independence. If this time my people fail to reunify and sell their honour for money, I ll quit to be Kurd! I quited to be muslim already. This Allah is god of Arabs, Turks and Persians not mine.
shia no one like them | 31/7/2014
why shia are so pussy. lol their army.
HowCanIHelp | 31/7/2014
Kurds have inhabited the lands they currently inhabit for thousands of years. The Kurds are the largest nation (40 million) without a state. Kurds are distinctly different from Arabs, Turks and Persians. The Kurds were told by Western countries they would have their own country after WWI. Instead, they were separated into regions in Turkey, Syria, Iran and Iraq. Kurds have been routinely persecuted by the governments of Turkey, Syria, Iran and Iraq. The Kurds practice democracy. The Kurds are currently protecting the minority refugees of Iraq and Syria in Northern Iraq which is under Kurdish control. These minorities include: Christians, Shabaks, Turkmen and Yazidis. No U.S. soldier has ever been killed in Kurdish controlled territory. The Kurds are planning a memorial to U.S. military men and women killed in Iraq. The first of its kind on foreign soil since the Normandy memorial. The Peshmerga (Kurdish army) are fierce fighters and have inflicted heavy casualties against ISIS. Please sign the following White House Petition supporting an independent Kurdistan. https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/support-kurdish-independence/wk7K9SSp Please write or call your political representatives and voice support for the Kurds. Thank you
KIM | 31/7/2014
An inch past Kirkuk and Kurdish territories should be none of our business
Mihvan Batifi | 31/7/2014
Arin Meberg, The process of seeking endepence will continue no matter we go to Baghdad or not. Actually is better to go and make sure that we cant get along with Baghdad and arabs then declare our Kurdish state, in order to show the world that we tried to get alone with arabs/Baghdad.
Print Email to a friend
Save this story
7182 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

KPatriot | 12/20/2014 6:26:53 PM
Serkeftin. Biji Peshmerga, YPG, PKK u hemi Kurd!
Official: Peshmerga inside Shingal, ISIS militants demoralized
| 6 hours ago | (1)
Andrew Martin | 12/20/2014 5:58:50 PM
Throughout history, force has been met, effect has been meted, the strongest has prevailed...I don`t care who you are, from what Denomination,what...
Jaiho | 12/20/2014 6:24:03 PM
Kurdish forces are like angels to the stranded Yazidi families in Mount Shingal.
Kurdish forces kill dozens of European, African ISIS fighters
| yesterday at 08:55 | (40)
Kurdistan | 12/20/2014 6:01:57 PM
Don't let them escape! and go to syria and finish them there to! close that road who led them out of shingal!
Hight Time | 12/20/2014 6:02:11 PM
Hight time to declare the independence of the Kurdish State.The free world is with us.High time for Rojave to join the nascent Kurdish state.Great...
UPDATE: ISIS defeated in Shingal, forced to retreat to Syria
| 12 hours ago | (19)
KPatriot | 12/20/2014 5:02:13 PM
"which has led to the mass exodus, no such attacks have been recorded in Kurdistan Region." With all due of respect, however there was one ugly...
Anas.Brwari.Chicago.U.S | 12/20/2014 5:38:56 PM
The best political solution for our Assyrian brothers is guarantee an region autonomy in Ninva plain within KRG federalizim and it's capital has to...
Assyrian official: Iraqi state failed to protect us
| 10 hours ago | (9)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Kurdish town hopes Americans will return to abandoned air base 12/11/2014 | (21)

Kurdish town hopes Americans will return to abandoned air base

Speculation circulates that Harir will host a new more
Bringing Silicon Valley to Erbil: teaching Kurds to “do world domination” 11/11/2014 | (19)

Bringing Silicon Valley to Erbil: teaching Kurds to “do world domination”

Swedish start-up coach offers advice to more
Despite rising violence, hope remains for Turkey-PKK peace talks, think-tank says 7/11/2014 | (14)

Despite rising violence, hope remains for Turkey-PKK peace talks, think-tank says

Peace talks not yet broken, report shows. more
0.438 seconds