Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Is Hamid Karazai Afghanistan’s Nuri Maliki

By Namo Abdulla 3/2/2014
Photo : AP
Photo : AP

Washington, DC – In his State of the Union address on Tuesday, President Obama renewed his commitment to withdraw US troops in Afghanistan by the end of the year.

But he said the US preferred to leave “a small” number of US troops in Afghanistan, where they can engage in both training Afghan forces and carrying out irregular raids on radical militants.

But Afghan President Hamid Karazai has not yet agreed to a security agreement that would allow for US troops to stay past 2014.

This somehow reminds us of Iraq, where Prime Minister Nuri Maliki, under pressure from Iran and anti-American domestic figures such as Muqtada al-Sadr, was not willing to extend the presence of any number of US troops after 2011.

In his recently published book, Robert Gates calls the complete withdrawal of US troops from Iraq a "victory" for Iran.

Iraq has recently seen a spike in violence and resurgence of al-Qaeda affiliated militants.

Now there is similar fear about the resurgence of Islamic militants in Afghanistan.

So is Hamid Karazai Afghanistan’s Nuri Maliki? What are the challenges facing the U.S. with Hamid Karazai? Are we going to see the repeatition of what many see as the Iraq mistake?

To discuss this subject, Rudaw’s Namo Abdulla talks to:

-Marvin Weinbaum, a political scholar at the Middle East Institute. He previously served as an analyst on Afganistan at the State Dept.

- Scott Bates, President of the Center for National Policy at the Truman National Security Project joins. Bates has worked in Afghanistan as part of an American team to promote democracy and good governance in the country.
Tags :
Print Email to a friend
Save this story

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Robledal Pedregoso | 1/26/2015 11:58:57 PM
Dear Heroic Kurdestani Regions: Ask Turkish, Iraqi , Syrian and Iranian regimes the only acceptable status is a cross-border Kurdish Federation where...
dijwar | 1/27/2015 2:37:01 AM
Come on people. I am a Kurd from Turkey. Kurdish people had many rights in last 12 years where they hadn't had for in the last 70 years. I am...
Turkish PM: I want to speak Kurdish as well as I speak Turkish
| yesterday at 07:18 | (37)
FAUthman | 1/26/2015 8:04:38 PM
To the authors of the above rather obvious comments about Iran, what is then the solution? How about some ideas on how to deal with Iran. We know how...
Mike | 1/27/2015 2:23:58 AM
Krg should allow isis to enter Iran through Kurdish territory so that there are problems for Iranians within their borders. It's better if Iran and...
Iraqi PM: We are working with Iranian general in war against ISIS
| 25/1/2015 | (16)
Robledal Pedregoso | 1/26/2015 11:25:34 PM
Dogiam and Ashad are like Hitler and Stalin two sides of the same coin and the Angel of Death will send them to Satan's luxurious villa to party with...
Freedom for Kurdistan | 1/27/2015 2:16:10 AM
You're both tyrants and Kurd killers. Now stop whining.
Assad: Erdogan is ‘personally responsible’ for Syrian chaos
| 23 hours ago | (18)
Kurdish Patriot | 1/26/2015 11:28:45 PM
Dahh!! Smart move!!? I wonder which dickhead thought about this strategy? So, to free ourselves from Sunni ISIS, we get the Iran lead Shiites to...
John Dingler, artist | 1/27/2015 2:15:29 AM
Why does am-Amri want to liberate Kurdistani Kurkuk from Kurds?
Militia leader: Diyala under control, preparing for Tikrit and Kirkuk
| yesterday at 06:29 | (26)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

What Is Turkey's Future Under Erdogan? 4 hours ago |

What Is Turkey's Future Under Erdogan?

Where will his worldview take Turkey and the more
State Department: US Has no Ban on Oil Sales from Any Part of Iraq 1/8/2014 | (35)

State Department: US Has no Ban on Oil Sales from Any Part of Iraq

“Iraq’s energy resources belong to all of the more
0.469 seconds