Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using



كوردى | Kurdî | English


Is Hamid Karazai Afghanistan’s Nuri Maliki

By Namo Abdulla 3/2/2014
Photo : AP
Photo : AP

Washington, DC – In his State of the Union address on Tuesday, President Obama renewed his commitment to withdraw US troops in Afghanistan by the end of the year.

But he said the US preferred to leave “a small” number of US troops in Afghanistan, where they can engage in both training Afghan forces and carrying out irregular raids on radical militants.

But Afghan President Hamid Karazai has not yet agreed to a security agreement that would allow for US troops to stay past 2014.

This somehow reminds us of Iraq, where Prime Minister Nuri Maliki, under pressure from Iran and anti-American domestic figures such as Muqtada al-Sadr, was not willing to extend the presence of any number of US troops after 2011.

In his recently published book, Robert Gates calls the complete withdrawal of US troops from Iraq a "victory" for Iran.

Iraq has recently seen a spike in violence and resurgence of al-Qaeda affiliated militants.

Now there is similar fear about the resurgence of Islamic militants in Afghanistan.

So is Hamid Karazai Afghanistan’s Nuri Maliki? What are the challenges facing the U.S. with Hamid Karazai? Are we going to see the repeatition of what many see as the Iraq mistake?

To discuss this subject, Rudaw’s Namo Abdulla talks to:

-Marvin Weinbaum, a political scholar at the Middle East Institute. He previously served as an analyst on Afganistan at the State Dept.

- Scott Bates, President of the Center for National Policy at the Truman National Security Project joins. Bates has worked in Afghanistan as part of an American team to promote democracy and good governance in the country.
Tags :
Print Email to a friend
Save this story

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

MMS | 7/22/2014 11:26:37 PM
The opinion as I read it was merely fair and balanced. Unfortunately you're not able to access intelligence reports which would give a better view....
Erdil | 7/24/2014 1:56:46 AM
Hamas like Isisis is nothing more than a Psychotic, systematic Jewish Western hating death cult glorifying murder masquerading as nationalism and...
Analysis: Dim Prospects for Israel-Hamas Ceasefire
| 22/7/2014 | (5)
KIM | 7/24/2014 12:21:00 AM
Its tome for Kurds to stand up for their rights in all parts! Freedom is not granted. Its taken!
MIKTAG | 7/24/2014 1:34:09 AM
Namo, I wish you could one day learn to ask relevant questions.
Iraq Crisis: Opportunity or Threat For Kurds
| 6 hours ago | (2)
aNgrYbiRd | 7/24/2014 12:24:48 AM
Why should one party have the exclusive right to presidency or any other post? That means you can't become a president unless you are PUK?. Sounds...
AkarHawleri | 7/24/2014 12:31:06 AM
Is this a joke? What the fuck happen to Barham Salih? I swear people of Kurdistan is done with PUK. They are all traitors and opportunist. #PUK #Iran...
Kurds Elect Fouad Massoum to be Iraq’s Next President
| 5 hours ago | (3)
Renas | 7/23/2014 8:04:51 PM
@AssyrianKing,You say we have no history? But our history is that the Meds destroyed your tyrant ASS people thousands of years ago. Go back to your...
Botani | 7/24/2014 12:27:13 AM
Assyrian Pimp In my books Iraqi Christian (past history) are very much like Baath party cunts or very much Isis fighter that is way I never...
No End to Christian Suffering as Iraq Staggers in Turmoil
| 21/7/2014 | (34)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Barzani: America, Turkey will not block Kurdish independence 6/7/2014 | (63)

Barzani: America, Turkey will not block Kurdish independence

Massoud Barzani, president of Iraq’s autonomous more
Muslims Challenge Caliphate Claim 6/7/2014 | (24)

Muslims Challenge Caliphate Claim

A man identified in an online video as Abu Bakr more
For Baghdad Residents Caught in Iraq Upheaval, Returning Home is a Problem 6/7/2014 | (2)

For Baghdad Residents Caught in Iraq Upheaval, Returning Home is a Problem

“There is no business left for us." more
0.328 seconds