Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Let’s Give Oil a Fair Chance

By Yerevan Saeed 11/12/2013

Oil, a major contributor to violence in Iraq in the past, is about to find its own natural course through decentralization of its management, exploration and extraction.

Unfortunately, the old ruling mentality still exists in Baghdad, unable to accept the new Iraq under a new constitution. Such thinking tries to play by the old rules and pushes the country to its disastrous past by insisting on centralized power over natural resources.

What is more unfortunate here is the position of the US Department of State about how oil should be managed in Iraq. The State Department continues to make statements in support of Baghdad’s authority over the country’s oil and gas without any concrete legal grounds. This harks back to the way Britain supported the Iraqi government against Kurdish aspirations during its reign in Iraq.

Of course, the US has been a big contributor to the realization of Kurdish aspirations. It has assisted the Kurds in getting the status they have today.  Washington may fear that disturbing the status quo in Iraq may lead to a bigger conflict -- a view that in fact might be wrong.

The current situation in the country seems to be untenable, given the security, sectarian, social and political issues that have riddled Iraq. Let us make sure that the oil issue does not get mixed up with this, such that natural resources are blamed for unwanted consequences.

In what is happening now, one can see some parallels between the US policy on Erbil-Baghdad issues and British policies in Iraq during the first half of the 20th century.

When Britain formed Iraq, oil was a major factor in condemning the Kurds to be unwillingly attached to the current state of Iraq. Then Britain sided with Baghdad and continued its unconditional support for the government it formed, without considering the demands of the Kurds.

Had Britain implemented a balanced approach towards the demands of the Kurds and its puppet government in Baghdad, Iraq might not have gone through this continuous vicious cycle of violence for decades.

There are lessons here for the United States. If this 80-year-old failed policy does not change, the consequences could be unbearable for everyone in the years to come.

So, let us not blame oil for much of the curse, but rather wrong policies. Should oil be given its neutral role and the right policies are prescribed, it would only result in peace and prosperity between Erbil and Baghdad.

* Yerevan Saeed, graduate of the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy in Boston.



MIB | 16/12/2013
Oil, I hate oil! If it weren't for oil Kurdistan would have been independent 100 years ago! Oil breeds lazy bastards. Just look at Saudi Arabia. Oil kills progress. Oil kills environment. I am afraid oil has already started to affect the mentality of my fellow Kurds. They already feel entitled to everything without working. Just like the Arabs...
Tags :

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

René Descartes | 10/3/2015 7:31:19 AM
Let's hope that such a deal will not hold since the Russians are targeting the Turkish allied islamists in first instance.Idlib must fall under...
Turkey No Fly Zone is to Choke Rojava | 10/3/2015 1:02:02 PM
If Idlib stays controlled by Turkey-supported Islamists, then Rojava is further isolated from Assad's rump state in Western Syria. Rojava needs a...
The Geopolitics Behind the Idlib Deal
| yesterday at 06:49 | (4)
I promote Truth | 10/3/2015 8:50:51 AM
I think AKP might win this election. AKP might regain votes from Conservative Muslim Kurds and since the son of the founder of MHP, named Tugrul...
I promote Truth | 10/3/2015 8:53:08 AM
'Demirtas said the party would recognize Israel as an “occupying” force and supports the Palestinians in their “political and armed struggle.”...
Demirtas kicks off HDP election campaign
| yesterday at 03:37 | (9)
Hamadamin | 10/3/2015 2:31:18 AM
The stupid Kurdish leadership should start an arms manufacturing program instead of begging the Americans and the Germans for weapons. Kurdistan is...
franzmaximilian | 10/3/2015 8:49:10 AM
Kak Hamadamin, your idea of Kurdistan manufacturing arms is pure fantasy and misleading the true efforts that are needed. Military firearms shall...
Ministry: 1,300 Peshmerga dead since start of war with ISIS
| 1/10/2015 | (8)
Turkey = ISIS | 10/3/2015 6:28:31 AM
Kurds should cut a deal with Russia if they want to have an independent Kurdistan, there's NO time to waste, the US/Turkey/ISIS will do nothing good...
I promote Truth | 10/3/2015 8:44:56 AM
Only 1 of 20 Airstrikes are on ISIS. Russia is still not serious in their war on ISIS.
Russian jets pound ISIS capital in Syria as coalition voices anger
| yesterday at 10:06 | (19)
0.219 seconds